| Speech Etiquette: The
Perspective From Cross-cultural Communication |
| Don't bring your own laws
to another's monastery. (Russian saying) |
|
I've been an ESL instructor for over 9 years, and
I am still amazed how little I know about the language that I teach.
Even if we do possess remarkable innate language abilities (Chomsky,
75), I have a growing suspicion that my entire life will be not
enough to learn everything about English.
A year ago I came to America to teach at Hinds Community College,
in Raymond, MS, and noticed that one of the major challenges with
which the Russian exchange students and faculty have been dealing
is the problem of cross-cultural communication. Belonging to a different
culture we found some local language phenomena quite out of the
ordinary. English expressions and customs are based on the American
culture and are characterized by the fact that it is not possible
for foreigners to comprehend them without losing some sense. Those
basic specific elements of linguistics culture impeding our understanding
of certain speech fragments are called lacunas (from Latin pit,
gap). Would you find it strange to have your health inquired after
three times in a row according to Afghani tradition? Isn't it weird
when the Chinese ask if a guest is tired after the meal? Likewise,
I assure you that some American speech peculiarities look quite
bizarre to Russians. Having spent almost a year in America, I've
made some observations on the curious language lacunas of the English
speech etiquette and behavior patterns. In my research I've been
actively using American movies as an abundant source of various
present-day English dialogues which provide illustrations to my
notes.
Addressing: In Russia and the U.S., two young
people when first meeting call each other by their first names.
But in Russia use of first names is completely inappropriate in
conversation between adults, who should address each other by their
first and patronymic (father's) names at all times. If a person
calls anyone who looks older by the first name, it's an insult unless
they are close friends. An exchange from Legends of the Fall
emphasizes this point:
|
|
-You like exotic-looking
dogs then, Miss Finncannon?
- Very much, Mr. Ludlow. Please call me Susannah.
- All right.
(00:08:48, Legends of the Fall, Columbia Tristar, 1994) |
 |
|
| Giving and receiving compliments:
When people first greet each other in the U.S., they often give compliments
on appearance, whether on the tie, the shirt, or a new haircut. In
Russia we pay compliments, too, but this is rarely done to strangers.
During her last visit to the U.S., my college president wore her embroidered
shoes with pointed up toes. While sightseeing, she was pleasantly
surprised to receive compliments on her beautiful shoes from complete
strangers. This aspect of commenting on one's appearance is reflected
in one of my favorite movies, Forrest Gump: |
|
- Those must be comfortable shoes.
I bet you could walk all day in shoes like that and not feel
a thing. I wish I had shoes like that.
- My feet hurt.
(00:03:54, Forrest Gump, Paramount Pictures, 1994) |
 |
|
|
Greetings: Another language lacuna is that
in America we may ask a person about his life and never get a real
answer. Phrases like "How're you doing? How do you do? What's
up?" are not questions any more. Somehow they turned into greeting
clichés which require the same cliche in return.
Both in the U.S. and in Russia, country people tend
to greet everybody they meet, regardless of whether they know each
other. Although there are quite a lot of people on campus, I've
always been very amazed and pleased to be greeted by students that
I've never seen before. I wouldn't mind if one day we had this custom
on our Russian campus; otherwise, you will be misunderstood. A hypothetical
exchange between an American and Russian students might look like
this:
- Hi, how're you doing!
- Excuse me, have we met?
Complaining: I see now that display of "bad
feelings" in Anglo-American culture may be seen as serving
no useful purpose and either damaging to person's "image"
or unpleasant for other people (Goddard, 38). No matter how hard
life is and how bad they feel, the Americans generally try to look
better than they really are, and a reply of "Fine, thank you"
provides them a cheerful "mask" to cover their true emotions.
Russians are more likely to answer honestly. They might reveal their
complaints and troubles, even though some are now adopting the American
habit of an always positive response. This is clearly demonstrated
in the dialogue from Lost in Translation:
|
|
[Phone Line Ringing]
- Hello?
- [Trembling] Lauren?
- Charlotte! Hey!
- Hey.
- Oh, my God. How's Tokyo?
- [Almost crying] It's great here. It's really great.
Um, I don't know... I went to this shrine today.
- Mm-hmm?
- And, um, there were these monks and they were chanting. And
I didn't feel anything. You know? And, um, I don't know... I
even tried ikebana, and John is using these hair products. I
just... I don't know who I married.
- Look, can you wait a second? Just hold on. I'll be right back.
- Okay, sure.
- Sorry. What were you saying?
- [Trembling] Nothing. It's okay. I'll call you later.
Okay?
- Okay. Have the best time. Just call me when you get back.
Bye. Love you.
- Bye.
(00:13:12, Lost in Translation, Focus Features, 2003) |
 |
|
|
Invitation: I've never thought that going
to party would confuse me so much. That confusion started with a
little talk:
- I am having a party. Can you all come?
- I think I can. I'll bring a salad.
If you were to hear this dialogue in Russia, the next line would
be the following: "Excuse me? You are going to do what? Bring
a salad? You must be kidding!"
If you are invited to a party in Russia, the host will provide all
of the food. An invited guest never asks to help by bringing food.
Even a birthday party is held not by the friends but by the one
who celebrates his or her birthday. One is welcome to bring something
to eat or drink, but it should be more like a gift: a box of chocolates
or a bottle of wine. When the party is over, we don't even think
of taking back home what is left. People would never invite us again
after such an outrageous act of greed.
Native speakers often forgive
phonological, syntactic and lexical errors as clear signs that a
speaker does not have native control of a language; however, they
typically interpret sociolinguistic errors as breaches of etiquette
rather than the transfer of different sociolinguistic rules (Boxer,
2). My hope is that in our ESL classes we could find more time to
spend on explaining the aspects of cross-cultural communication,
for a successful conversation is based not only on good command
of the foreign language but also on cultural competence of the speakers.
Works Cited
Boxer, Diana. Complaining and Commiserating. New York: Peter Lang
Publishing, 1993.
Chomsky, Noam. The Logical Structure of Linguistic Theory. New York:
Plenum Press, 1955.
Goddard, Cliff. Explicating Emotions Across Languages and Cultures:
A Semantic Approach. Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers,
2002.
|
|
| |
|
|